Report Exposes Racial Bias in Healthcare Systems

A separate group examining racism within South Africa's health insurance systems has confirmed its previous conclusions indicating that Black medical professionals faced significantly higher rates of accusations related to fraudulent activity, misuse, and mismanagement (FWM) between 2012 and 2019.

Although the report recognizes certain advancements since 2020, it contends that underlying disparities remain prevalent.

On Monday, Advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi stated that Black professionals had a notably higher chance of being convicted for FWA compared to those who were not Black, highlighting a concerning rate of risk.

A multi-year inquiry examined information from prominent health insurance providers such as Discovery Health, Medscheme, and GEMS, encompassing the timeframe between 2012 and mid-2019.

A statistical study carried out by Dr. Zaid Kimmie, the panel's specialist, revealed that Black healthcare professionals were as much as three times more prone to be deemed guilty of fraud under these programs.

In some fields, like physical therapy and psychiatry, the risk factors were significantly elevated, with chances being up to six to twelve times more likely.

Following accusations from Black health care professionals and organizations such as Solutionist Thinkers and the National Health Care Professionals Association (NHCPA) regarding racial bias in fraudulent claims examinations in early 2019, an investigation has been launched.

The Medical Schemes Council (CMS) initiated an external investigation, establishing the Section 59 Inquiry Committee, which gathered numerous reports claiming unjust discrimination against Black professionals via forensic reviews and pressure-based contracts.

The involved groups sought assistance from the Minister of Health, Dr Aaron Motsoaledi.

A tripartite committee comprised Ngcukaitobi, head of the Section 59 Inquiry Panel, Advocate Adila Hassim, and Advocate Kerry Williams.

Three campaigners finished their tasks and delivered the concluding report, containing conclusions and suggestions, to the Minister of Health for review on Monday afternoon.

The committee restated important suggestions from its preliminary report, such as establishing early alert mechanisms to inform suppliers about possible FWA issues prior to imposing penalties, along with an examination of audit timelines, contending that recovering payments for three years may lead to excessive difficulties.

"Here we faced severe evidence regarding healthcare professionals who are compelled to shut down their clinics as they can barely sustain operations without support from health insurance programs. In situations where they must reimburse funds that were reclaimed by these schemes, some of them struggle to cover expenses for their own families," said Ngcukaitobi.

They further recommended offering mediation assistance to facilitate equitable discussions between programs and alleged service providers.

The report highlighted the importance of ensuring equal access for all parties involved, but did not recommend a particular method for resolving disputes.

The investigation revealed that these systems had a greater negative effect on Black healthcare professionals, damaging their sense of self-worth and career status.

The CMS has been encouraged to enforce stricter yearly evaluation of race-based risk rates within various healthcare fields to avoid potential biased actions in the future.

Reforms

Although the committee acknowledged certain process enhancements made by health insurance providers, it emphasized that additional changes are required to tackle long-standing prejudices within fraud identification mechanisms.

Following the release of the preliminary report in 2021, certain programs have made adjustments to their FWA frameworks.

As per the report, Medscheme launched an innovative AI-powered system named DOTS, whereas GEMS updated its communication strategies to enhance cooperation with service providers.

Discovery Health created a panel of health professionals to enhance equity within forensic procedures.

Nevertheless, the committee highlighted that substantial deficiencies still exist, especially regarding maintaining openness.

The document emphasized the importance of continuous oversight of FWA systems to avoid biased results and maintain constitutional values of fairness.

The committee highlighted that although they were not a legal tribunal, their conclusions revealed widespread disparities in how health insurance plans handle medical professionals according to race.

Review

Motsoaledi has further highlighted the pressing necessity to eliminate two entirely different healthcare systems—one designed for the affluent and another for those less fortunate.

The Minister referred to it as "extremely distressing" and emphasized that today's healthcare environment resembles the disjointed structure of 14 distinct health departments prior to 1994.

In the meantime, Motsoaledi has pledged to examine the whole healthcare system and tackle issues related to health insurance rules and billing procedures.

Furthermore, he also discussed strategies aimed at merging healthcare systems via programs such as the National Health Insurance (NHI).

The official cautioned that although the report has been submitted, possible legal disputes could emerge, especially once the suggestions start being put into action.

Nevertheless, he feels that the inquiry marks an important move toward tackling deep-rooted disparities within South Africa's medical system, indicating possible substantial changes ahead.

Copyright 2025 SAnews.gov.za. All rights reserved. Shared via AllAfrica Global Media (Https://Positivibemind.ocm).

Tagged: South Africa, Health and Medicine, Human Rights, Southern Africa

Supplied by SyndiGate Media Inc. ( Syndigate.info ).